The ticking timebomb scenarioby now a philosophical cliche posits an encounter with an apprehended terrorist suspect who allegedly knows the whereabouts of a ticking timebomb hidden in a densely populated area. Defusing the ticking bomb scenario association for the. In such a timeconstrained scenario, policymakers may. Fawkes was caught in the act of trying to blow up parliament, and the information he subsequently provided under torture was useless. The fallacy of the ticking timebomb scenario 596 words. The ticking time bomb scenario is a thought experiment that has been used in the ethics debate over whether torture can ever be justified. The idea is a hypothetical scenario in which authorities arrest a potential suspect who they believe might know the location of a bomb and refuses to give. If torture is going to be administered as a last resort in the tickingbomb case, to save enormous numbers of lives, it ought to be done openly, with accountability, with. Mar 03, 2003 if torture is going to be administered as a last resort in the ticking bomb case, to save enormous numbers of lives, it ought to be done openly, with accountability, with approval by the president. Apr 30, 2014 people avoid the ticking time bomb because the hypothetical is a debating trap. I focus on the ticking bomb scenario because it offers my opponents strongest argument and if even the strongest argument for torture fails, then any use of torture is always wrong.
Ncjrs abstract national criminal justice reference service. For more than a century, much of the world has condemned the general. Although standard ethical views categorize intentional torture as morally wrong, the ticking time bomb ttb scenario is frequently offered as a legitimate counterexample that justifies the use of torture. I know that victims of torture will offer intentionally misleading information if they think their captors will believe it. Morality does not require us to build a general policy on. Dershowitzs proposal for judicially sanctioned torture.
Does an utilitarian approach require the use of torture in the ticking time bomb ttb scenario. The prohibition of torture in exceptional circumstances can torture be justifi ed in exceptional circumstances. Anything that can prevent a disaster from happening should be looked upon as an option. Taken as a whole, these circumstances are so unlikely to occur that, even if the ticking bomb scenario would justify the use of torture, it has not ever occurred and, therefore, cannot be used to justify torture. The dramatic story of a ticking bomb scenario in which a goodnatured hero is presented with the difficult sole option of torturing a suspect in custody in order to save innocent lives has been told and retold in the media and other facets of public discourse. Mar 18, 2010 orsolic, tina, the prohibition of torture and the ticking time bomb scenario march 17, 2010. Torture, ticking time bombs, and waterboarding americans. The ticking time bomb could be the economy or as simple as a biological clock.
The ticking time bomb scenario is most commonly used as means for justification when it comes to torture. There is one major point that can be brought up against this argument. In terms of the philosophical literature, an early formulation owes to a seminal essay by henry shue. Oct 15, 2015 the general consensus among philosophers is that the use of torture is never justified. During the composition of this piece, the new york times. Torture is not an option in the famous time bomb scenario. Even so, the ticking time bomb scenario keeps coming up. Jun 24, 2011 even so, the ticking time bomb scenario keeps coming up. In the standard ticking bomb scenario, a suspect has. Ticking time bomb scenario definition of ticking time. The scariest scenario for the next major earthquake may not be from the san andreas fault though that one still threatens, but from the hayward fault that runs along the east side of the san francisco bay. The ticking bomb scenario survivors of torture, international. It asks us to imagine a case where only torture can prevent the detonation of a bomb that will kill millions.
Crim 4 ticking bomb and torture flashcards quizlet. In that play, the american government has established a protocol of intensified interrogation for terrorist suspects which requires participation of the fbi, cia and the department of justice. Pdf abstract much of the literature on torture in recent years takes. However, the ticking time bomb scenario does pose a unique set of challenges that must be discussed at length before such a situation ariscs. The use of torture has become a prominent matter of dispute as we enter an age of the global war on 1600 words 7 pages. On the one hand, to represent some type of ticking bomb scenario, the timing of attack must be far enough.
What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link. Taken as a whole, these circumstances are so unlikely to occur that, even if the ticking bomb scenario would justify the use of torture, it has not ever occurred and, therefore, cannot be. In addition the ticking bomb scenario requires a great deal of certainty about the suspect in custody, the potential threat, and hisher relationship to the threat. According to mayfield, full certainty is not possible in reality and the subsequent risk of torturing innocent civilians is inevitable. It is also a favorite of shows like 24 whose purpose is to dignify torture and to justify it in an entertainment format. The prohibition of torture and the ticking timebomb scenario. Reassessing the thought experiment the terrorist attacks on 911 and the subsequent so called war on terror led to a flurry of discussion about whether, under some very special circumstances, a liberal democracy could legally and morally use torture to protect its citizens. Even though they know the bomb exists, they dont know when and where its going to go off. Zhaiti, liberia, and ethiopia between nation, race, and the world 191945 kathryn medien. The most common argument in favor of torture in the current literature is the ticking bomb argument. The ticking time bomb scenario is a thought experiment that has been used in the ethics debate. For instance, the ticking bomb scenario typically supposes certainty, or near certainty, as to all of the following. Reassessing the thought experiment in advance article pdf available in the international journal of applied philosophy january 2015 with 5 reads.
She argues that the ticking bomb scenario is a fi ction that. In such a time constrained scenario, policymakers may. Ticking time bomb scenario definition of ticking time bomb. I am against any form of torture but if it leads to saving innocent life then anything should be done at that point to. The socalled ticking timebomb scenario is analogous to the just war case of. It is only in relatively modern times, shklar thinks, that we have come to put cruelty firstthat is, regard it as the most vicious of all vices. When has the ticking time bomb scenario happened in real.
Liberalism, torture, and the ticking bomb scholarship. The moderate position on torture then, that it may be permissible in ticking bomb cases, is impractical and is an abstraction of how reality actually functions. Applying this reasonableness test to the ticking bomb scenario, torturing the ticking bomb terrorist would qualify as an unreasonable seizure of the suspect in violation of the fourth amendment. In this timely work, michelle farrell asks how and why this question has become such a central debate. We may face situations where large numbers of us citizens face an imminent threat. The person in custody is a perpetrator of the attack. The ticking timebomb defense of torture is evasive and. With the use of the ticking time bomb scenario, some make a desirable case that in special circumstances, there is a right to torture individuals implicated is acts of mass violence. In terrorism, ticking timebombs, and torture, fritz allhoff demonstrates the weakness of the case against torture. There is no time to evacuate the innocent people or even the movable art treasuresthe. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Ethics i know from personal experience that the abuse of prisoners will produce more bad than good intelligence, he said. Aug 03, 2007 the scenario the ticking bomb problem. Dec 15, 2014 on ticking time bombs the ticking time bomb scenario is a tv trope and, therefore, is a terrible guide for making policy.
Pdf although standard ethical views categorize intentional torture as morally wrong, the ticking time bomb ttb scenario is frequently offered. The gunpowder plot wasnt a ticking time bomb scenario. Petraeus resurrects the ticking time bomb scenario the. The author further argues that torture is an institution, requiring a bureaucracy with apprentices and experts. The ticking timebomb scenario serves a second rhetorical goal, one that is. Harm done to one person can provide information that saves the lives of many moral liability. The problem that even the most virtuous people face when thinking about torture is whether there is ever a case when a good result produced by torture. On ticking time bombs the ticking time bomb scenario is a tv trope and, therefore, is a terrible guide for making policy. The most convincing argument that torture may be necessary is the ticking time bomb scenario featured on 24. Most often the phrase is used semantically to mean that an urgent event is about to occur. The dispatches are fascinating and well worth reading in themselves, but i was particularly struck by an anecdote in todays dispatch, involving a guest lecture that haim ben ami, a former head of interrogations at shin bet, gave to one of alan dershowitzs harvard law school classes about the infamous ticking timebomb scenario. The ticking timebomb defense of torture is evasive and irrelevant prominent apologists for harsh cia interrogations keep invoking a scenario that everyone agrees never happened. Liberalism, torture, and the ticking bomb important than cruelty. Morality does not require us to build a general policy on torture around a situation that is not merely.
Hayward bay fault line more dangerous than san andreas. Yet, blanket condemnations of torture are often countered with this type of hypothetical situation. The person has information that will prevent the attack. The problem that even the most virtuous people face when thinking about torture is whether there is ever a case when a good result produced by torture justifies the evil act of torturing someone. The general consensus among philosophers is that the use of torture is never justified. Torture might be justified in the famous ticking timebomb scenario. With the use of the ticking time bomb scenario, some make a desirable case that in special circumstances, there is a right to. Separation of cases, ticking timebombs and moral justificationpdf international journal of applied. It is now thought to be the ticking time bomb fault line and more dangerous than the san andres.
Dershowitz and the ticking timebomb fantasy opinio juris. However, looking back up to the ticking time bomb scenario, it is a given fact that the person in custody has the information. The ticking time bomb scenario is subject of the drama the dershowitz protocol by canadian author robert fothergill. In this scenario, a bomb has been placed in a city by a terrorist, and the only way to defuse the bomb in time is to torture a terrorist in custody for information. The ticking time bomb full episode subtitled duration. As a thought experiment, there is no need that the scenario be plausible.
Ticking time bomb scenario synonyms, ticking time bomb scenario pronunciation, ticking time bomb scenario translation, english dictionary definition of ticking time. Torture, he argues, is not for amateurs, but requires practice and mentoring. Aug 16, 2014 although standard ethical views categorize intentional torture as morally wrong, the ticking time bomb ttb scenario is frequently offered as a legitimate counterexample that justifies the use of torture. For instance, the ticking bomb scenario typically supposes certainty, or. Jeremy wisnewski, understanding torture 12848 2010 providing an extensive critique of the unrealistic ticking time bomb scenario.
However, after careful examination, the scenario is flawed and filled with fallacies. The ticking bomb argument, where a terrorist is tortured in order to. The threat of terrorism facing our nation today is a large scale problem that would be more appropriately addressed by focusing on methods of increasing national security without infringing on human dignity. To justify the use of torture, torturefetishists often cite the hypothetical ticking time bomb scenario, in which an imminent threat can be stopped in time only if we brutalize a prisoner to obtain information about the threat. She thinks that montaigne and montesquieu, both of them protoliberals, were the first politi.
Finally, torture is the best means to try to get this information from the suspect mccoy, 2006. Ticking time bomb scenario synonyms, ticking time bomb scenario pronunciation, ticking time bomb scenario translation, english dictionary definition of ticking time bomb scenario. In terrorism, ticking time bombs, and torture, fritz allhoff demonstrates the weakness of the case against torture. In michael walzers classic example, a politician must decide. Orsolic, tina, the prohibition of torture and the ticking timebomb scenario march 17, 2010. They capture a person who knows where and when the ticking time bomb goes off. Although his particular version has become well known, he was not the first to devise a scenario of this sort. Assumptions of the scenario the ticking bomb is based on a number of assumptions, some of which may be hidden or only implied when it is first presented.
1259 543 1542 932 765 36 1486 329 365 781 1219 9 380 644 638 1125 351 845 397 1503 430 167 1070 785 757 1227 893 996 438 231 892 1322 914 419 1458 153 65 343 665 943 691